Who was the crucified, Prophet Jesus or his disciples?
Book Al-Quran has clearly stated that unlicensed they never kill the prophet Jesus, not even crucify him. They kill or they cross it is another person who was likened to the face of the prophet Jesus' upon whom be peace.
And as people Kurani, we must take offense with an attitude committed by a Christian brother. This kerana they have made a very fatal lie, saying that unlicensed they had killed or crucified.
Moreover, until there is a story of Prophet Jesus walking on the road with barbed wire, carry the cross, added to the story of atonement. Of course all the story was clearly contrary to the ultimate truth, both according to historians especially according to the Quran.
In the Al-Quran, clearly stated that unlicensed prophet Jesus was never crucified by anyone. And also he was never killed.
and kerana their saying, "We killed the Messiah, 'Isa son of Maryam, Messenger of God", but they did not kill him and not crucified, but someone who was likened to Jesus for them. Those who quarreled about Jesus, is really in doubt about who killed it. They do not have a belief about who killed him, except to follow mere conjecture, they do not believe that unlicensed and they killed it was' Isa. (Surah An-Nisa ': 157)
This verse suggests with no cover, that unlicensed all just a lie, a fantasy, imagination and stories that are not clear ancestral origins. At least there is never a saheeh chain history point which should be back on those stories.
If we compare with the science of hadith criticism of our religion, history about the crucifixion of Jesus is like the hadith prophet who da'eef jiddan (very weak), the title perawinya akdzabunnas (man most falsely) that would never pass in the selection of al-jarhu watta ' dil. Even isnaad is disconnected, alian munqathi 'or else mursal.
Even according to other hadith scholars have classified hadith may maudhu '(false). And in Islam, it is definitely false hadith categorically rejected, let alone used, would not be visited.
But unfortunately, our brother kerana Christian religion that does not have a system of hadith criticism as we have, so the stories of different versions out devastated their religious history, even to the most fundamental areas, namely the problem aqidah.
So every year when our brethren died commemorate the day Jesus Christ, we as Muslims will be proud, we've got science kerana hadith criticism. So all the story, a story or narration unclear accountability jawabnnya, will never be allowed to enter into the religious teachings of Islam.
And the science of hadith criticism was already proved his ability for 14 centuries is to maintain the purity of this religion from a variety of stories that are not clear Hayal tip base. And the tragedy of lack of clarity is the source of the greatest tragedies that befell two divine religions, Christian and Jewish.
But as Muslims, we are still obliged to respect what became of their beliefs. We must never interfere with what else menghalagi what they do. But the name discussion, dialogue and study of history rather than means to be stopped.
At least we'll say that free you please just make different versions of the story, but we saranana for your religion not abandoned by the adherents, create stories that have cubalah accountability Reply Ilmiyah. Since the more honest we are on history, the more it will make people believe the truth of our religion.
Conversely, the more we have no concern for historical authenticity, then people will increasingly abandon what we dakwahi.
So Who the crucified
Al-Quran does not expressly identify who crucified. Which affirmed the Koran was that it was not the prophet who crucified Jesus' upon whom be peace. Al-Quran confirms that unlicensed, he was appointed to his side.
But God has raised Jesus to him. And Allah is Mighty, Wise. (Surah An-Nisa ': 158)
So there are a variety of history about the person who was crucified. Sebahagian history says that unlicensed who crucified Jesus was a disciple of the prophet that is most like him. His disciples who narrated this amounted to only 12 people competing to be the change, claiming to be prophet Jesus to protect their teacher.
But in another history, the crucifixion was a man named Judas Eskariot, a Jew who was likened by the prophet of Allah SWT be like Jesus.
And there are so many other versions. But that is true, certainly the crucified or killed was not a prophet of Jesus' upon whom be peace. Thus beliefs about atonement that is not recognized in all divine religions treatise, clearly did not find irrelevant.
Beliefs about penance came from European nations of ancient beliefs, when religion was later taken there. Or incorporated by Paul who was too much to change the religion into a new religion, which is almost 100% irrespective of the original religion that Allah sent down.
Even a Michael Hart who are not Muslims even explicitly stated that unlicensed Paul (Paul?) Was actually the founder of Christianity today, and not the prophet Jesus. Kerana the basics of that religion at this day, is no longer the same as those brought by the prophet Jesus.
In his book 100: A Ranking of the Most Influental Person in History, Michael Hart wrote:
"The influence of Paul in the development of Christian Religion can be measured by three things. First, the triumph of magnitude in the spread of religion. Second, his writings that make up an important portion-portion of the New Testament. Third, its role in the development of theology Kristian.
Of the 27 books of the New Testament, no less than 14 associated with the services Paul. Although modern scientists think 4 or 5 books of the 14 were written by someone else, but no doubt that free Paul was the most important person in peribadi wrote the New Testament.
Effect of Paul in the fields of theology Kristian really indescribable magnitude. Idea-idea include the following: Jesus is not just a prophet but also sacred. Jesus died for our sins and misery to free us. Humans can not escape from the sins simply by mencuba execute the commands listed in the Gospel, but should only be by way of receiving Jesus soul.
Conversely, when people receive and believe in Jesus, his sins will be forgiven. Paul also explains its doctrines of sin (see Romans 5: 12:19). "
In another page, Michael Hart added:
"Paul, more than other people, responsible for the transition of the Christian Religion Jewish tribe become the world's great religions. The central idea of the sanctity of Jesus and recognition based on trust alone remains the rationale Kristian throughout the centuries that followed. "
So, let us build a better dialogue and discussion Ilmiyah, not just blind faith, but faith-literate with historical reality.
And Allaah 'lam bishshawab, wassalamu alaikum Warahmatullahi wabarakatuh,
No comments:
Post a Comment